Samuel: People Desire a King; he Protests
Jump to: Nave'sLibrarySubtopicsTerms
Topical Encyclopedia
In the biblical narrative, the prophet Samuel plays a pivotal role during a transitional period in Israel's history, as the nation shifts from a theocratic system of judges to a monarchy. This transition is marked by the people's demand for a king, which Samuel initially protests, reflecting a significant moment in the spiritual and political life of Israel.

Context and Background

Samuel, a prophet, judge, and leader of Israel, was dedicated to the Lord by his mother, Hannah, and served under Eli the priest at Shiloh. As he grew, Samuel became recognized as a prophet of the Lord, and his leadership was instrumental in guiding Israel during a time of moral and spiritual decline. The narrative of the people's demand for a king is found in 1 Samuel 8.

The People's Demand

As Samuel aged, he appointed his sons as judges over Israel. However, his sons did not follow his righteous ways; they were corrupt, accepting bribes and perverting justice (1 Samuel 8:3). Discontent with this situation, the elders of Israel approached Samuel at Ramah with a request: "Behold, you are old, and your sons do not walk in your ways. Now appoint a king to judge us like all the other nations" (1 Samuel 8:5).

Samuel's Protest

Samuel was displeased with the people's request for a king, as it signified a rejection of the Lord's direct rule over Israel. He prayed to the Lord, who instructed him to heed the people's voice but to solemnly warn them about the implications of having a king. The Lord said to Samuel, "Listen to the voice of the people in all that they say to you. For it is not you they have rejected, but they have rejected Me as their king" (1 Samuel 8:7).

The Warning

Samuel conveyed the Lord's warning to the people, detailing the rights of a king and the burdens he would impose: conscription of sons for military and agricultural service, daughters for perfumers and cooks, the best of their fields and vineyards taken, and a tenth of their grain and flocks claimed (1 Samuel 8:11-17). Despite these warnings, the people persisted in their demand, desiring to be like other nations with a king to lead them and fight their battles.

The Lord's Instruction

After hearing the people's insistence, the Lord instructed Samuel to comply with their request. "Listen to their voice and appoint a king for them," the Lord said (1 Samuel 8:22). Samuel then instructed the people to return to their cities, setting the stage for the anointing of Saul as Israel's first king.

Significance

This episode highlights the tension between divine sovereignty and human authority. The people's desire for a king reflects a lack of faith in God's provision and protection, opting instead for a human leader to emulate surrounding nations. Samuel's protest underscores the spiritual implications of this choice, as it represents a shift away from the unique covenant relationship between God and Israel. The narrative serves as a cautionary tale about the consequences of rejecting divine authority in favor of human governance.
Nave's Topical Index
1 Samuel 8:4-22
Then all the elders of Israel gathered themselves together, and came to Samuel to Ramah,
Nave's Topical Index

Library

Chronicles
... to the exile of Judah; and the natural desire to see ... 2 Samuel 24:1 Jehovah had tempted
David to number the people. ... In 1 Samuel 28:6 it is implicitly said that ...
/.../mcfadyen/introduction to the old testament/chronicles.htm

Royal Murderers
... Naboth, in the presence of the people, saying, Naboth ... Samuel's warning of what a
king would be and do ... in passion, and every gratifying of desire against which ...
/.../maclaren/expositions of holy scripture f/royal murderers.htm

Letter xxii. To Eustochium.
... to go out from your own land unless you forget your people and your ... reward do I receive
for this?" The context shows""The king shall desire thy beauty ...
/.../jerome/the principal works of st jerome/letter xxii to eustochium.htm

The Christ Crowned, the Fact
... drawing away to prayer, the hunger for God's Word, the intense desire to have ... in
Paul's day and ever since, and now, is to get people to take. ... 12] 1 Samuel 16:6 ...
/.../i the christ crowned the fact.htm

The Old Testament and Archeology
... But I saw my desire upon him and his house ... Joshua, Judges, Samuel, Kings, they include
in the list of ... give a complete history even of {149} the Hebrew people. ...
/.../the christian view of the old testament/chapter iv the old testament.htm

Chapter i.
... is interested in the antiquities of the Jewish people [30 ... have for the most part
shewn no desire to disturb ... iv.1903, v.1907; SR Driver, Notes on Samuel (Introd. ...
/.../an introduction to the old testament in greek additional notes/chapter i.htm

The Deists.
... As a rule, they showed no desire to separate ... Thus Cudworth, Tillotson, Locke, and
Samuel Clarke were stigmatised as ... five pastoral letters to the people of his ...
/.../abbey/the english church in the eighteenth century/chapter iii the deists.htm

The Last Supper.
... "Perhaps," said Baruch, "you desire to take ... forth witnesses against him, otherwise
the people will believe ... least the law requires," and Samuel answered: "These ...
//christianbookshelf.org/stead/king of the jews/chapter iii the last supper.htm

What Carey did for Literature and for Humanity
... in his physique and knowledge to Dr. Samuel Johnson, and even ... He knew the people
of India, their religious, social, and ... the god had made known its desire to be ...
/.../smith/the life of william carey/chapter xi what carey did.htm

The Great Schism
... Samuel Finley, afterwards president of Princeton, was imprisoned ... of such laws as
debarred people from enjoying ... nearing completion, and their desire was that ...
/.../chapter x the great schism.htm

Resources
What were the emerods God afflicted the Philistines with in 1 Samuel 5? | GotQuestions.org

Who was David in the Bible? | GotQuestions.org

Did the witch of Endor really summon Samuel from the dead (1 Samuel 28:7-20)? | GotQuestions.org

Samuel: Dictionary and Thesaurus | Clyx.com

Bible ConcordanceBible DictionaryBible EncyclopediaTopical BibleBible Thesuarus
Subtopics

Samuel

Samuel the Prophet

Samuel: A Judge (Leader) of Israel, his Judgment Seat at Beth-El, Gilgal, Mizpeh, and Ramah

Samuel: A Prophet of the Israelites

Samuel: Anoints David to be King

Samuel: Anoints Saul to be King of Israel

Samuel: Blessed of God

Samuel: Called Shemuel

Samuel: Called up by the Witch of Endor

Samuel: Chronicles of

Samuel: Consecrated to God Before his Birth

Samuel: Death of; the Lament for Him

Samuel: His Integrity As a Judge and Ruler

Samuel: His Mother's Song of Thanksgiving

Samuel: His Vision Concerning the House of Eli

Samuel: Israelites Repent Because of his Reproofs and Warnings

Samuel: Makes his Corrupt Sons Judges in Israel

Samuel: Ministered in the House of God

Samuel: Miraculous Birth of

Samuel: Organizes the Tabernacle Service

Samuel: People Desire a King; he Protests

Samuel: Renews the Kingdom of Saul

Samuel: Reproves Saul; Foretells That his Kingdom Will be Established

Samuel: Shelters David While Escaping from Saul

Samuel: Sons of

Samuel: The Philistines Defeated Through his Intercession and Sacrifices

Statecraft: Samuel

Related Terms

Samuel's (6 Occurrences)

Shammah (8 Occurrences)

Ziklag (13 Occurrences)

Seer (21 Occurrences)

Ziba (13 Occurrences)

Keilah (16 Occurrences)

Servant's (29 Occurrences)

Zeru'iah (24 Occurrences)

Stronghold (68 Occurrences)

Arrows (59 Occurrences)

Zobah (15 Occurrences)

Zeruiah (25 Occurrences)

Valour (66 Occurrences)

Seemeth (36 Occurrences)

Asahel (17 Occurrences)

Kingship (17 Occurrences)

Seeketh (60 Occurrences)

Sorrowing (33 Occurrences)

Valiant (66 Occurrences)

Shemesh (24 Occurrences)

Spear (55 Occurrences)

Shield (65 Occurrences)

Zuph (3 Occurrences)

Kei'lah (16 Occurrences)

Kish (18 Occurrences)

Victory (71 Occurrences)

Keepeth (60 Occurrences)

Stature (22 Occurrences)

Suckling (19 Occurrences)

Son-in-law (14 Occurrences)

Severely (48 Occurrences)

Kenites (8 Occurrences)

As'ahel (17 Occurrences)

Seeks (48 Occurrences)

Sweareth (34 Occurrences)

Spared (45 Occurrences)

Starting (34 Occurrences)

Kine (24 Occurrences)

Youths (28 Occurrences)

Kissed (26 Occurrences)

Syrians (63 Occurrences)

Shimei (43 Occurrences)

Arrow (34 Occurrences)

Skirt (16 Occurrences)

Smiting (76 Occurrences)

Station (78 Occurrences)

Vowed (34 Occurrences)

Sovereign (209 Occurrences)

Violated (23 Occurrences)

Ziph (9 Occurrences)

Saul's (79 Occurrences)

Scattered (122 Occurrences)

Shamed (91 Occurrences)

Saveth (36 Occurrences)

Surrender (18 Occurrences)

Stepped (16 Occurrences)

Sacrificing (39 Occurrences)

Array (63 Occurrences)

Stronger (59 Occurrences)

Safety (72 Occurrences)

Arts (48 Occurrences)

Voices (76 Occurrences)

Seems (99 Occurrences)

Setteth (116 Occurrences)

Vashni (1 Occurrence)

Kiriathjearim

Ascend (86 Occurrences)

Shiloh (34 Occurrences)

Sling (11 Occurrences)

Kiss (39 Occurrences)

Kiriath-jearim (17 Occurrences)

Spoil (140 Occurrences)

Subdued (41 Occurrences)

Standeth (111 Occurrences)

Soldiers (83 Occurrences)

Street (54 Occurrences)

Articles (78 Occurrences)

Slept (74 Occurrences)

Success (29 Occurrences)

Samuel: Organizes the Tabernacle Service
Top of Page
Top of Page