Matthew 23:19
You blind men! Which is greater: the gift, or the altar that makes it sacred?
You blind men!
This phrase is a direct rebuke from Jesus, highlighting the spiritual blindness of the religious leaders. The Greek word for "blind" is "τυφλοί" (typhloi), which metaphorically refers to a lack of understanding or insight. In the context of first-century Judaism, the Pharisees and scribes were seen as spiritual guides, yet Jesus exposes their inability to perceive the true essence of God's commandments. This blindness is not physical but spiritual, indicating a deeper ignorance of God's will and the heart of the law.

Which is greater
Here, Jesus poses a rhetorical question to challenge the priorities and values of the religious leaders. The Greek word for "greater" is "μείζων" (meizōn), suggesting a comparison of importance or value. This question forces the Pharisees to reconsider their misplaced emphasis on external rituals over internal devotion. It is a call to discern what truly holds weight in the eyes of God, urging a return to the heart of worship rather than mere ceremonial observance.

the gift
The "gift" refers to offerings or sacrifices brought to the temple. In the Jewish tradition, these gifts were acts of worship and devotion, often seen as a means to gain favor with God. However, Jesus points out that the value of the gift is not inherent but is derived from its association with the altar. The Greek word for "gift" is "δῶρον" (dōron), which can also mean a present or offering. This highlights the tendency of the religious leaders to focus on the material aspects of worship rather than the spiritual significance behind them.

or the altar
The "altar" is central to Jewish worship, serving as the place where sacrifices are made to God. The Greek word "θυσιαστήριον" (thysiastērion) refers to this sacred structure. Historically, the altar was seen as a meeting point between God and man, a place of atonement and reconciliation. By questioning the relative importance of the altar and the gift, Jesus emphasizes the altar's role in sanctifying the offering, pointing to the deeper spiritual truths that the religious leaders have overlooked.

that makes it sacred?
The phrase "makes it sacred" underscores the transformative power of the altar. The Greek word "ἁγιάζω" (hagiazō) means to sanctify or set apart as holy. This indicates that the altar, as a symbol of God's presence and covenant, imparts holiness to the gift. Jesus is teaching that the true sanctity of worship comes not from the external act itself but from its connection to God. This challenges the Pharisees to recognize that their focus should be on the divine relationship rather than the ritualistic details.

Persons / Places / Events
1. Jesus Christ
- The speaker of this verse, addressing the Pharisees and scribes with a rebuke for their misguided priorities and spiritual blindness.

2. Pharisees and Scribes
- Jewish religious leaders known for their strict adherence to the law and traditions, whom Jesus often criticized for their hypocrisy and legalism.

3. The Altar
- A sacred place in the temple where offerings were made to God, symbolizing the presence and holiness of God.

4. The Gift
- Refers to the offerings or sacrifices brought to the altar, which the Pharisees considered more important than the altar itself.

5. Jerusalem
- The city where the temple was located, serving as the religious and cultural center for the Jewish people.
Teaching Points
Spiritual Blindness
Jesus calls out the Pharisees for their inability to see the true spiritual priorities. We must examine our own lives for areas where we might be blind to God's priorities.

True Worship
The altar represents God's presence and holiness. Our worship should focus on God Himself, not just the rituals or offerings we bring.

Heart Over Ritual
God values the condition of our hearts over the external acts of worship. We should prioritize inner transformation and obedience to God's will.

Hypocrisy Warning
Jesus warns against the hypocrisy of valuing traditions over God's commands. We should strive for authenticity in our faith and practice.

Sacredness of God's Presence
The altar's sacredness comes from God's presence. We should approach God with reverence and prioritize His presence in our lives.
Bible Study Questions
1. How does Jesus' rebuke of the Pharisees in Matthew 23:19 challenge our understanding of what is truly sacred in our worship practices?

2. In what ways can we ensure that our worship and offerings to God are not just ritualistic but come from a sincere heart?

3. How can we identify and address areas of spiritual blindness in our own lives, as Jesus pointed out in the Pharisees?

4. What are some modern-day "gifts" or offerings that we might mistakenly prioritize over the presence and holiness of God?

5. How can the teachings in Matthew 23:19 be applied to promote authenticity and integrity in our personal and communal worship experiences?
Connections to Other Scriptures
Matthew 5:23-24
Jesus emphasizes the importance of reconciliation and the heart's condition over mere ritualistic offerings.

Hebrews 13:10
Discusses the spiritual altar that Christians have, which is greater than the physical altars of the Old Covenant.

1 Samuel 15:22
Highlights the principle that obedience to God is more important than sacrifices, aligning with Jesus' teaching on the heart's priority over ritual.

Isaiah 1:11-17
God expresses His disdain for empty rituals and emphasizes justice and righteousness, echoing Jesus' critique of the Pharisees.
Pharisees and SadduceesMarcus Dods Matthew 23:2-33
Ostentatious ProfanityR. Hall.Matthew 23:16-22
SwearingJ.A. Macdonald Matthew 23:16-22
The AltarC. H. Spurgeon.Matthew 23:16-22
Thoughtless ProfanityE. H. Chopin, D. D.Matthew 23:16-22
Unreasonable OathsM. Pool.Matthew 23:16-22
People
Abel, Barachias, Berechiah, Hen, Jesus, Zachariah, Zacharias, Zechariah
Places
Jerusalem
Topics
Altar, Blind, Fools, Gift, Greater, Holy, Important, Makes, Offering, Ones, Sacred, Sanctifies, Sanctifieth, Sanctifying, Whether
Dictionary of Bible Themes
Matthew 23:1-32

     8767   hypocrisy

Matthew 23:1-33

     5381   law, letter and spirit
     8749   false teachers

Matthew 23:1-36

     5379   law, Christ's attitude
     7552   Pharisees, attitudes to Christ

Matthew 23:2-33

     7464   teachers of the law

Matthew 23:13-33

     9250   woe

Matthew 23:13-39

     2318   Christ, as prophet

Matthew 23:16-19

     5135   blindness, spiritual

Matthew 23:16-22

     5430   oaths, human

Matthew 23:18-20

     7302   altar

Library
The Morality of the Gospel.
Is stating the morality of the Gospel as an argument of its truth, I am willing to admit two points; first, that the teaching of morality was not the primary design of the mission; secondly, that morality, neither in the Gospel, nor in any other book, can be a subject, properly speaking, of discovery. If I were to describe in a very few words the scope of Christianity as a revelation, [49] I should say that it was to influence the conduct of human life, by establishing the proof of a future state
William Paley—Evidences of Christianity

Jesus' Last Public Discourse. Denunciation of Scribes and Pharisees.
(in the Court of the Temple. Tuesday, April 4, a.d. 30.) ^A Matt. XXIII. 1-39; ^B Mark XII. 38-40; ^C Luke XX. 45-47. ^a 1 Then spake Jesus ^b 38 And in his teaching ^c in the hearing of all the people he said unto ^a the multitudes, and to his disciples [he spoke in the most public manner], 2 saying, ^c 46 Beware of the scribes, ^a The scribes and the Pharisees sit on Moses' seat: 3 all things whatsoever they bid you, these do and observe: but do not ye after their works: for they say, and do not.
J. W. McGarvey—The Four-Fold Gospel

Christianity Misunderstood by Believers.
Meaning of Christian Doctrine, Understood by a Minority, has Become Completely Incomprehensible for the Majority of Men-- Reason of this to be Found in Misinterpretation of Christianity and Mistaken Conviction of Believers and Unbelievers Alike that they Understand it--The Meaning of Christianity Obscured for Believers by the Church--The First Appearance of Christ's Teaching--Its Essence and Difference from Heathen Religions-- Christianity not Fully Comprehended at the Beginning, Became More and
Leo Tolstoy—The Kingdom of God is within you

First Attempts on Jerusalem.
Jesus, almost every year, went to Jerusalem for the feast of the passover. The details of these journeys are little known, for the synoptics do not speak of them,[1] and the notes of the fourth Gospel are very confused on this point.[2] It was, it appears, in the year 31, and certainly after the death of John, that the most important of the visits of Jesus to Jerusalem took place. Many of the disciples followed him. Although Jesus attached from that time little value to the pilgrimage, he conformed
Ernest Renan—The Life of Jesus

For which Cause Our Lord Himself Also with his Own Mouth Saith...
4. For which cause our Lord Himself also with His own mouth saith, "Cleanse what are within, and what are without will be clean." [1813] And, also, in another place, when He was refuting the foolish speeches of the Jews, in that they spake evil against His disciples, eating with unwashen hands; "Not what entereth into the mouth," said He, "defileth the man: but what cometh forth out of the mouth, that defileth the man." [1814] Which sentence, if the whole of it be taken of the mouth of the body,
St. Augustine—On Continence

Relation of the Pharisees to the Sadducees and Essenes, and to the Gospel of Christ
On taking a retrospective view of Pharisaism, as we have described it, there is a saying of our Lord which at first sight seems almost unaccountable. Yet it is clear and emphatic. "All therefore whatsoever they bid you observe, that observe and do" (Matt 23:3). But if the early disciples were not to break at once and for ever with the Jewish community, such a direction was absolutely needful. For, though the Pharisees were only "an order," Pharisaism, like modern Ultramontanism, had not only become
Alfred Edersheim—Sketches of Jewish Social Life

Among the People, and with the Pharisees
It would have been difficult to proceed far either in Galilee or in Judaea without coming into contact with an altogether peculiar and striking individuality, differing from all around, and which would at once arrest attention. This was the Pharisee. Courted or feared, shunned or flattered, reverently looked up to or laughed at, he was equally a power everywhere, both ecclesiastically and politically, as belonging to the most influential, the most zealous, and the most closely-connected religions
Alfred Edersheim—Sketches of Jewish Social Life

The General Service to a Prophet.
At the Vespers, for O Lord, I have cried, the Stichera, Tone 4. Similar to: Called from above... Thou that hast in the purity of thy mind received the reflex of the God-emitted light and wast the herald of the divine words and seer and divine prophet, thou appearedst as the God-moved mouth of the Spirit, conveying that which was shewn by Him unto thee, O all-honoured (mentioned by name), and declaring unto all the peoples the salvation that was being granted and the Kingdom of Christ; do entreat
Anonymous—The General Menaion

Of the Power of Making Laws. The Cruelty of the Pope and his Adherents, in this Respect, in Tyrannically Oppressing and Destroying Souls.
1. The power of the Church in enacting laws. This made a source of human traditions. Impiety of these traditions. 2. Many of the Papistical traditions not only difficult, but impossible to be observed. 3. That the question may be more conveniently explained, nature of conscience must be defined. 4. Definition of conscience explained. Examples in illustration of the definition. 5. Paul's doctrine of submission to magistrates for conscience sake, gives no countenance to the Popish doctrine of the obligation
John Calvin—The Institutes of the Christian Religion

Hints to Teachers and Questions for Pupils
Teacher's Apparatus.--English theology has no juster cause for pride than the books it has produced on the Life of Paul. Perhaps there is no other subject in which it has so outdistanced all rivals. Conybeare and Howson's Life and Epistles of St. Paul will probably always keep the foremost place; in many respects it is nearly perfect; and a teacher who has mastered it will be sufficiently equipped for his work and require no other help. The works of Lewin and Farrar are written on the same lines;
James Stalker et al—The Life of St. Paul

On Attending the Church Service
"The sin of the young men was very great." 1 Sam. 2:17. 1. The corruption, not only of the heathen world, but likewise of them that were called Christians, has been matter of sorrow and lamentation to pious men, almost from the time of the apostles. And hence, as early as the second century, within a hundred years of St. John's removal from the earth, men who were afraid of being partakers of other men's sins, thought it their duty to separate from them. Hence, in every age many have retired from
John Wesley—Sermons on Several Occasions

Machinations of the Enemies of Jesus.
Jesus passed the autumn and a part of the winter at Jerusalem. This season is there rather cold. The portico of Solomon, with its covered aisles, was the place where he habitually walked.[1] This portico consisted of two galleries, formed by three rows of columns, and covered by a ceiling of carved wood.[2] It commanded the valley of Kedron, which was doubtless less covered with debris than it is at the present time. The depth of the ravine could not be measured, from the height of the portico; and
Ernest Renan—The Life of Jesus

The Early Ministry in Judea
113. We owe to the fourth gospel our knowledge of the fact that Jesus began his general ministry in Jerusalem. The silence of the other records concerning this beginning cannot discredit the testimony of John. For these other records themselves indicate in various ways that Jesus had repeatedly sought to win Jerusalem before his final visit at the end of his life (compare Luke xiii. 34; Matt. xxiii. 37). Moreover, the fourth gospel is confirmed by the probability, rising almost to necessity, that
Rush Rhees—The Life of Jesus of Nazareth

The Crossing of the Jordan
THE CROSSING OF THE JORDAN Just how did you feel at the time you were sanctified? I have heard some tell of how the holy fire of the Spirit seemed to go all through them. Others have told of a deeper, more complete peace. Some have shouted for joy. Others have wept for joy. And I am wondering how one ought to feel. Can you tell me? And how can I know that I am consecrated? Every teacher of entire sanctification that I ever heard says that the consecration must be complete; but how am I to know when
Robert Lee Berry—Adventures in the Land of Canaan

Subjects of Study. Home Education in Israel; Female Education. Elementary Schools, Schoolmasters, and School Arrangements.
If a faithful picture of society in ancient Greece or Rome were to be presented to view, it is not easy to believe that even they who now most oppose the Bible could wish their aims success. For this, at any rate, may be asserted, without fear of gainsaying, that no other religion than that of the Bible has proved competent to control an advanced, or even an advancing, state of civilisation. Every other bound has been successively passed and submerged by the rising tide; how deep only the student
Alfred Edersheim—Sketches of Jewish Social Life

Letter Xliv Concerning the Maccabees but to whom Written is Unknown.
Concerning the Maccabees But to Whom Written is Unknown. [69] He relies to the question why the Church has decreed a festival to the Maccabees alone of all the righteous under the ancient law. 1. Fulk, Abbot of Epernay, had already written to ask me the same question as your charity has addressed to your humble servant by Brother Hescelin. I have put off replying to him, being desirous to find, if possible, some statement in the Fathers about this which was asked, which I might send to him, rather
Saint Bernard of Clairvaux—Some Letters of Saint Bernard, Abbot of Clairvaux

Number and Order of the Separate Books.
The number of the books was variously estimated. Josephus gives twenty-two, which was the usual number among Christian writers in the second, third, and fourth centuries, having been derived perhaps from the letters of the Hebrew alphabet. Origen, Jerome, and others have it. It continued longest among the teachers of the Greek Church, and is even in Nicephorus's stichometry.(83) The enumeration in question has Ruth with Judges, and Lamentations with Jeremiah. In Epiphanius(84) the number twenty-seven
Samuel Davidson—The Canon of the Bible

Elucidations.
I. (Who first propounded these heresies, p. 11.) Hippolytus seems to me to have felt the perils to the pure Gospel of many admissions made by Clement and other Alexandrian doctors as to the merits of some of the philosophers of the Gentiles. Very gently, but with prescient genius, he adopts this plan of tracing the origin and all the force of heresies to "philosophy falsely so called." The existence of this "cloud of locusts" is (1) evidence of the antagonism of Satan; (2) of the prophetic spirit
Hippolytus.—The Refutation of All Heresies

"The Carnal Mind is Enmity against God for it is not Subject to the Law of God, Neither Indeed Can Be. So Then they that Are
Rom. viii. s 7, 8.--"The carnal mind is enmity against God for it is not subject to the law of God, neither indeed can be. So then they that are in the flesh cannot please God." It is not the least of man's evils, that he knows not how evil he is, therefore the Searcher of the heart of man gives the most perfect account of it, Jer. xvii. 12. "The heart is deceitful above all things," as well as "desperately wicked," two things superlative and excessive in it, bordering upon an infiniteness, such
Hugh Binning—The Works of the Rev. Hugh Binning

We are not Binding Heavy Burdens and Laying them Upon Your Shoulders...
37. We are not binding heavy burdens and laying them upon your shoulders, while we with a finger will not touch them. Seek out, and acknowledge the labor of our occupations, and in some of us the infirmities of our bodies also, and in the Churches which we serve, that custom now grown up, that they do not suffer us to have time ourselves for those works to which we exhort you. For though we might say, "Who goeth a warfare any time at his own charges? Who planteth a vineyard, and eateth not of the
St. Augustine—Of the Work of Monks.

Repentance and Impenitence.
In the discussion of this subject I shall show,-- I. What repentance is not. 1. The Bible everywhere represents repentance as a virtue, and as constituting a change of moral character; consequently, it cannot be a phenomenon of the intelligence: that is, it cannot consist in conviction of sin, nor in any intellectual apprehension of our guilt or ill-desert. All the states or phenomena of the intelligence are purely passive states of mind, and of course moral character, strictly speaking, cannot be
Charles Grandison Finney—Systematic Theology

Second Sunday after Trinity Exhortation to Brotherly Love.
Text: 1 John 3, 13-18. 13 Marvel not, brethren, if the world hateth you. 14 We know that we have passed out of death into life, because we love the brethren. He that loveth not abideth in death. 15 Whosoever hateth his brother is a murderer: and ye know that no murderer hath eternal life abiding in him. 16 Hereby know we love, because he laid down his life for us: and we ought to lay down our lives for the brethren. 17 But whoso hath the world's goods, and beholdeth his brother in need, and shutteth
Martin Luther—Epistle Sermons, Vol. III

Links
Matthew 23:19 NIV
Matthew 23:19 NLT
Matthew 23:19 ESV
Matthew 23:19 NASB
Matthew 23:19 KJV

Matthew 23:19 Commentaries

Bible Hub
Matthew 23:18
Top of Page
Top of Page