1 Samuel 14:41
So Saul said to the LORD, the God of Israel, "Why have You not answered Your servant this day? If the fault is with me or my son Jonathan, respond with Urim; but if the fault is with the men of Israel, respond with Thummim." And Jonathan and Saul were selected, but the people were cleared of the charge.
Then Saul said
This phrase introduces us to King Saul, the first king of Israel, who is seeking divine guidance. The Hebrew root for "said" is "אָמַר" (amar), which often implies a declaration or command. Saul's leadership is marked by moments of seeking God's will, though often with mixed motives. This moment reflects his reliance on divine intervention, a common practice for leaders in ancient Israel.

to the LORD, the God of Israel
The invocation of "the LORD" (YHWH) emphasizes the covenant relationship between God and Israel. "The God of Israel" underscores God's unique role as the protector and guide of His chosen people. This phrase reminds us of the historical context where Israel's identity and survival were deeply intertwined with their faithfulness to God.

Give a perfect lot
The term "perfect lot" refers to the casting of lots, a method used in ancient Israel to discern God's will. The Hebrew word for "lot" is "גּוֹרָל" (goral), which was a common practice for decision-making. The request for a "perfect" lot indicates Saul's desire for a clear and unambiguous answer from God. This reflects the belief in God's sovereignty and His ability to guide His people through seemingly random events.

And Saul and Jonathan were taken
The phrase indicates the outcome of the lot-casting, where Saul and his son Jonathan are singled out. The Hebrew root for "taken" is "לָכַד" (lakad), meaning to capture or seize. This moment is pivotal, as it sets the stage for revealing the cause of God's displeasure. It highlights the tension between Saul's leadership and Jonathan's righteousness.

but the people were cleared
This outcome exonerates the people of Israel, indicating that the issue lies with Saul or Jonathan. The Hebrew root for "cleared" is "יָצָא" (yatsa), meaning to go out or be free. This phrase reassures the Israelites of their innocence in the matter at hand, emphasizing God's justice and the importance of individual accountability within the community.

Persons / Places / Events
1. Saul
The first king of Israel, chosen by God but later rejected due to disobedience. In this passage, he seeks divine guidance through casting lots.

2. Jonathan
Saul's son, known for his bravery and faith in God. He plays a crucial role in the events leading up to this verse.

3. The LORD, the God of Israel
The covenant God of Israel, whom Saul seeks for guidance.

4. Casting Lots
An ancient practice used to discern God's will, often involving stones or other objects to make decisions.

5. The People
Refers to the Israelite army, who were not found guilty in this divine inquiry.
Teaching Points
Seeking Divine Guidance
Saul's use of lots underscores the importance of seeking God's will in decision-making. While the method may differ today, the principle of seeking divine guidance remains crucial.

The Role of Leadership
Saul's leadership is put to the test. Leaders are called to seek God's direction and act in accordance with His will, setting an example for others.

Faith and Obedience
Jonathan's earlier actions demonstrate faith and obedience, contrasting with Saul's later disobedience. Faithful actions often precede divine guidance.

God's Sovereignty
The casting of lots reflects God's control over all circumstances. Believers can trust that God is sovereign over the outcomes of their lives.

Community Accountability
The process of casting lots involved the entire community, highlighting the importance of accountability and transparency in communal decisions.
Bible Study Questions
1. How does Saul's request for a "perfect lot" reflect his understanding of God's sovereignty, and how can we apply this understanding in our decision-making today?

2. In what ways does the practice of casting lots in the Old Testament compare to seeking God's guidance through prayer and Scripture today?

3. How does Jonathan's faith and actions earlier in 1 Samuel 14 serve as a model for us in trusting God amidst challenging circumstances?

4. What lessons can we learn from Saul's leadership in this passage, and how can we apply these lessons to our roles in leadership or influence?

5. How does the concept of community accountability in this passage relate to the New Testament teachings on the body of Christ and mutual accountability among believers?
Connections to Other Scriptures
Joshua 7
The use of casting lots to identify Achan as the one who sinned, showing a precedent for seeking God's will in this manner.

Proverbs 16:33
Highlights the belief that the outcome of casting lots is determined by the LORD, reinforcing the idea of divine sovereignty.

Acts 1:26
The apostles cast lots to choose Matthias as Judas' replacement, showing continuity in seeking God's guidance through lots.
RashnessB. Dale 1 Samuel 14:24-46
A Bad Saving of TimeWayland Hoyt, D. D.1 Samuel 14:24-52
Acting from Mere ImpulseJ. A. Muller.1 Samuel 14:24-52
Great Issues Hang on a King's Rash WordFootsteps of Truth.1 Samuel 14:24-52
Saul's WilfulnessW. G. Blaikie, D. D.1 Samuel 14:24-52
The Rash OathHelen Plumptre.1 Samuel 14:24-52
People
Abiel, Abner, Ahiah, Ahijah, Ahimaaz, Ahinoam, Ahitub, Amalek, Amalekites, Ammonites, Benjamin, Eli, Ichabod, Ishui, Israelites, Jonathan, Kish, Malchishua, Melchishua, Merab, Michal, Ner, Phinehas, Saul
Places
Aijalon, Beth-aven, Bozez, Edom, Geba, Gibeah, Michmash, Migron, Moab, Seneh, Shiloh, Zobah
Topics
Captured, Chosen, Cleared, Decision, Declare, Escaped, Free, Guilt, Hast, Jonathan, Lot, Marked, O, Perfect, Perfection, Prayed, Saul, Servant, Sin, Testimony, Thummim, Urim
Dictionary of Bible Themes
1 Samuel 14:41

     8610   prayer, asking God

1 Samuel 14:24-46

     5187   taste

1 Samuel 14:24-47

     8479   self-examination, examples

1 Samuel 14:36-42

     8128   guidance, receiving

1 Samuel 14:41-42

     7392   lots, casting of

Library
The Roman Pilgrimage: the Miracles which were Wrought in It.
[Sidenote: 1139] 33. (20). It seemed to him, however, that one could not go on doing these things with sufficient security without the authority of the Apostolic See; and for that reason he determined to set out for Rome, and most of all because the metropolitan see still lacked, and from the beginning had lacked, the use of the pall, which is the fullness of honour.[507] And it seemed good in his eyes[508] that the church for which he had laboured so much[509] should acquire, by his zeal and labour,
H. J. Lawlor—St. Bernard of Clairvaux's Life of St. Malachy of Armagh

Jonathan, the Pattern of Friendship
'And David fled from Naioth in Ramah, and came and said before Jonathan, What have I done? what is mine iniquity? and what is my sin before thy father, that he seeketh my life? 2. And he said unto him, God forbid; thou shalt not die: behold, my father will do nothing either great or small, but that he will shew it me: and why should my father hide this thing from me? it is not so. 3. And David sware moreover, and said, Thy father certainly knoweth that I have found grace in thine eyes; and he saith,
Alexander Maclaren—Expositions of Holy Scripture

Of Antichrist, and his Ruin: and of the Slaying the Witnesses.
BY JOHN BUNYAN PREFATORY REMARKS BY THE EDITOR This important treatise was prepared for the press, and left by the author, at his decease, to the care of his surviving friend for publication. It first appeared in a collection of his works in folio, 1692; and although a subject of universal interest; most admirably elucidated; no edition has been published in a separate form. Antichrist has agitated the Christian world from the earliest ages; and his craft has been to mislead the thoughtless, by
John Bunyan—The Works of John Bunyan Volumes 1-3

A Divine Cordial
We know that all things work together for good, to them that love God, to them who are the called according to his purpose. Romans viii. 28. Introduction IF the whole Scripture be the feast of the soul, as Ambrose said, then Romans 8 may be a dish at that feast, and with its sweet variety may very much refresh and animate the hearts of Gods people. In the preceding verses the apostle had been wading through the great doctrines of justification and adoption, mysteries so arduous and profound, that
Thomas Watson—A Divine Cordial

Ramah. Ramathaim Zophim. Gibeah.
There was a certain Ramah, in the tribe of Benjamin, Joshua 18:25, and that within sight of Jerusalem, as it seems, Judges 19:13; where it is named with Gibeah:--and elsewhere, Hosea 5:8; which towns were not much distant. See 1 Samuel 22:6; "Saul sat in Gibeah, under a grove in Ramah." Here the Gemarists trifle: "Whence is it (say they) that Ramah is placed near Gibea? To hint to you, that the speech of Samuel of Ramah was the cause, why Saul remained two years and a half in Gibeah." They blindly
John Lightfoot—From the Talmud and Hebraica

Samuel
Alike from the literary and the historical point of view, the book[1] of Samuel stands midway between the book of Judges and the book of Kings. As we have already seen, the Deuteronomic book of Judges in all probability ran into Samuel and ended in ch. xii.; while the story of David, begun in Samuel, embraces the first two chapters of the first book of Kings. The book of Samuel is not very happily named, as much of it is devoted to Saul and the greater part to David; yet it is not altogether inappropriate,
John Edgar McFadyen—Introduction to the Old Testament

Links
1 Samuel 14:41 NIV
1 Samuel 14:41 NLT
1 Samuel 14:41 ESV
1 Samuel 14:41 NASB
1 Samuel 14:41 KJV

1 Samuel 14:41 Commentaries

Bible Hub
1 Samuel 14:40
Top of Page
Top of Page