Election in Massachusetts (1988)

On September 24, 1988, the Episcopal Diocese of Massachusetts elected the Rev. Barbara C. Harris, age 58, as suffragan bishop. The vote, taken in the diocese centered in and around Boston, marked the first time a woman was chosen for the episcopate within the Anglican Communion. Her consecration the following February confirmed what the election signaled: a watershed moment that would test consciences, friendships, and church order, and would force many believers to ask what faithfulness looks like when convictions collide.

Barbara C. Harris

Harris was widely known as a former communications executive and a longtime civil-rights advocate who entered ordained ministry later in life. Those close to her often spoke of fearless preaching, direct speech, and a pastor’s tenderness toward the wounded. Admirers saw courage in her willingness to step into a public storm for the sake of what she believed was God’s calling; even critics often acknowledged her gifts of leadership and her concern for the marginalized. Her story highlighted a Christian virtue often overlooked: perseverance—continuing to serve even when misunderstood.

Scripture, Order, and Calling

Her election drew celebration and opposition, exposing deep disagreements about how Scripture should be interpreted, how the historic ministry of bishops should be guarded, and how the church discerns vocation. The conflict reminded Christians that zeal can harden into contempt, and caution can harden into fear. Scripture calls believers to hold conviction without abandoning charity: “Instead, speaking the truth in love, we will in all things grow up into Christ Himself, who is the head” (Ephesians 4:15). The moment pressed many to examine whether their words built up the body or merely won arguments.

A Call to Humility and Love

In the strain that followed, believers were reminded to pray, to listen carefully, and to treat opponents as neighbors rather than enemies. Even in controversy, the church is summoned to a holy manner: “But in your hearts sanctify Christ as Lord. Always be prepared to give a defense… Yet do this with gentleness and respect” (1 Peter 3:15). Whatever one concluded about the decision, the event stands as a sober lesson: Christ’s people must contend with conscience, but walk with humility, repentance, and a love that refuses to dehumanize.